LNT and cancer risk assessment: Its flawed foundations part 2: How unsound LNT science became accepted
نویسندگان
چکیده
This paper argues that Edward B. Lewis served as a type of independent academic radiation LNT-cancer risk assessment-stalking horse for the BEAR Genetics Panel, task which he had no expertise or experience (e.g. radiation, leukemia, epidemiology and statistical modelling). His efforts produced an insufficiently documented, strongly biased, high-profile in Science (May 17, 1957), whose principal conclusions not been proven, asserted privately, writing. inconclusive perspective was well camouflaged published by means sophisticated wordsmithing. At time his department head George Beadle came to chair Panel summer 1956, Beadle-inspired-Lewis LNT activity acquired urgency when study 70,000 offspring from survivors A-bombs failed show genetic damage after decade careful study, undercutting recommendations. With Beadle's guidance, effort redirected Panel's focus atomic bomb acrimoniously disrupted relationships priorities, more immediate disciplinary/professional opportunities with concerns about fallout, leukemia risks new cancer causation role mutation. The serious limitations affected neither its publication nor receiving editorial endorsement, possibly due influence powerful members, such Bentley Glass, one only six senior editors Science. restored, even though improperly, scientific moral initiatives led directly multiple high level recommendations assessment based on Precautionary Principle, asserted, remains place today essentially all countries. present explores how long-shot quasi-stalking horse, who unsupported members during withering criticism prompted article, nevertheless endured pursuit goal, becoming strikingly successful achieving global revolution place.
منابع مشابه
Commentary on Using LNT for Radiation Protection and Risk Assessment.
An article by Jerome Puskin attempts to justify the continued use of the linear no-threshold (LNT) assumption in radiation protection and risk assessment. In view of the substantial and increasing amount of data that contradicts this assumption; it is difficult to understand the reason for endorsing this unscientific behavior, which severely constrains nuclear energy projects and the use of CT ...
متن کاملModel Uncertainty via the Integration of Hormesis and LNT as the Default in Cancer Risk Assessment
On June 23, 2015, the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) issued a formal notice in the Federal Register that it would consider whether "it should amend its 'Standards for Protection Against Radiation' regulations from the linear non-threshold (LNT) model of radiation protection to the hormesis model." The present commentary supports this recommendation based on the (1) flawed and deceptive ...
متن کاملFlaws in the LNT single-hit model for cancer risk: An historical assessment.
The LNT single-hit model was derived from the Nobel Prize-winning research of Herman J. Muller who showed that x-rays could induce gene mutations in Drosophila and that the dose response for these so-called mutational events was linear. Lewis J. Stadler, another well-known and respected geneticist at the time, strongly disagreed with and challenged Muller's claims. Detailed evaluations by Stadl...
متن کاملThe LNT Debate in Radiation Protection: Science vs. Policy.
There is considerable interest in revisiting LNT theory as the basis for the system of radiation protection in the US and worldwide. Arguing the scientific merits of policy options is not likely to be fruitful because the science is not robust enough to support one theory to the exclusion of others. Current science cannot determine the existence of a dose threshold, a key piece to resolving the...
متن کاملA Formal TLS Handshake Model in LNT
Testing of network services represents one of the biggest challenges in cyber security. Because new vulnerabilities are detected on a regular basis, more research is needed. These faults have their roots in the software development cycle or because of intrinsic leaks in the system specification. Conformance testing checks whether a system behaves according to its specification. Here model-based...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
ژورنال
عنوان ژورنال: Environmental Research
سال: 2021
ISSN: ['2752-5295']
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2021.111041